SNF Nostos

STAVROS NIARCHOS FOUNDATION

SNF Nostos Conference: Humanity and Artificial Intelligence
August 26 & 27, 2021

Thinkers and practitioners from a wide variety of fields—from the tech sector, to medicine, to politics, to the arts—came together at the 2021 SNF Nostos Conference on the theme of Humanity and Artificial Intelligence. Behind the incredibly complex topic of artificial intelligence are simple, human essential questions: What sort of world do we want to live in? And how do we get there?

The concept of artificial intelligence has been on humanity’s mind for thousands of years, and approaches have differed profoundly across cultural contexts, which participants explored in a panel on Narratives and Visions. “The first narrative for an intelligent machine was in the Iliad….People have been thinking of creating objects that are as intelligent and can interact with humans for millennia,” said Kanta Dihal, Senior Research Fellow at the University of Cambridge Leverhulme Centre for the Future of Intelligence.

“AI is not one thing, it is multiple technologies through a system of power. The question is how we can design a system were power is shared,” said Anasuya Sengupta, Founder & Co-Director of Whose Knowledge, in a panel focused on envisioning AI Futures Worth Wanting. Power dynamics—how they influence the creation of AI technologies and how AI technologies help shift or reinforce them—were a consistent undercurrent across a number of different discussions.

“We can’t ask ‘Is it good?’ We have to ask ‘Good for whom?’…. We are making tradeoffs all the time,” said Google AI Software Engineer, Software Architect, and Designer Blaise Aguera Y Arcas.

Even when AI is being used to deliver more widely shared benefits rather than harnessed for the benefit of a few, the outcomes may not be equal or fair. In the medical field, Dr. Barry Coller, Vice President for Medical Affairs at The Rockefeller University, commented in a panel on Meta-Patterns, “We have to deal with the fact that something may be fantastic for general decision-making but can be a catastrophe for the individual.”

In the arts, William Kentridge observed that algorithms are very good at optimizing, but that the “less good idea” is often what produces the best result. The discussion panels of the conference were interspersed with short performances related to artificial intelligence by artists including Kentridge, adding an additional avenue for inquiry and exploration.

As AI has the potential to fundamentally reshape our institutions, our social structures, and our ways of living, conference participants probed how those same structures, habits, and unquestioned assumptions have helped shape the form that AI has taken. Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein, President and CEO of the International Peace Institute, discussed how AI should be deployed during a panel on Discourse and Democracy. “We are now reaching some sort of existential moment and we need to change the competitive instinct, the commercial desire for profit into something that will allow our species to continue and not to destroy itself.”

“AI is trained by data. Data carries values. Values carry judgements. And therefore it embodies certain ethical perspectives on what is right, what is fair, and it embodies certain biases, conscious or unconscious, of a society,” said Nicolas Economou, Chair of the Science, Law, and Society Initiative at the Future Society and Principal Coordinator of the Athens Roundtable on AI and the Rule of Law in a panel on Connection, Competition and Cooperation.

The ethical challenges of developing new AI technologies concern not only the humans who interact with them, but also the technology itself. “I think on the way to building a machine that is conscious, that could think like a person,” said author Ted Chiang, “you will inevitably build a machine which is capable of suffering and then you will create a class of entity which is almost infinitely reproducible, which can experience suffering. Right now we have human suffering and we have animal suffering. I don’t think we need to create an additional category of entity which is capable of suffering.”

On the other hand, several speakers expressed optimism that seeing our own faults manifested and reflected back to us in artificial intelligence could be the impetus humanity needs to address our prejudices. “Is AI biased? It is like looking in the mirror and not liking what you see,” said Blaise Aguera Y Arcas.

However the relationship between humanity and AI evolves in the long term, a sense that the this evolution is already underway—and perhaps further along than we can appreciate—was widely shared. The first day of the conference closed with perspectives from the people who will be most affected by accelerating technological change: young people. Five students fielded questions, then turned the tables to ask questions of the adults in the room.

The discussion with the students struck an optimistic tone on the future of technology, affirming that real human connection is irreplaceable, and that younger generations are conscious of both the upsides and the downsides of using social media. Because perspectives like these, from the young people who will experience accelerating technological change more than anyone, are too often missing from the conversation, the Stavros Niarchos Foundation (SNF) announced the launch of a brand-new opportunity for them to share their perspectives. The SNF 25th Anniversary Short Film Challenge invites people ages 14 to 21 to share their ideas about how technology can be a force for good and win a chance to take their story to the next level with professional creators.

In his closing remarks, SNF Co-President Andreas Dracopoulos issued a collective call to embrace and engage with AI, and to direct our efforts toward shaping AI so that it better serves humanity. “We all need, as much as we can, to do all we can to help improve education, healthcare, justice, decency, compassion—to bring back hope, for every human soul in this world.”

Conference minutes and summary provided by iMEdD.

 

Speakers

Harshit Agrawal

Artist 

Read the bio 

Manolis Andriotakis

Journalist and Author

Read the bio

Blaise Aguera y Arcas

VP Fellow
Google Research

Read the bio

Refik Anadol

Μedia Artist 

Read the bio

Azeem Azhar

Writer

Read the bio

Sinan Aral

Director
MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy (IDE)

Read the bio

Daniel Barron

Medical Director, Interventional Pain Psychiatry Program
Brigham and Women's Hospital

Read the bio

Stelios Vassilakis

Chief Programs & Strategic Initiatives Officer
Stavros Niarchos Foundation 

Read the bio

Dimitris Bounias

Project Manager Ideas Zone & Incubator at iMEdD, Journalist

Read the bio

Anna Kynthia Bousdoukou

iMEdD Managing Director, SNF DIALOGUES Executive Director, Journalist

Read the bio

Anthi Bousouni

Student 

Read the bio

Rob Brooks

Scientia Professor of Evolution
UNSW

Read the bio

Stephen Cave

Executive Director
Leverhulme Centre for the Future of Intelligence, University of Cambridge

Read the bio

Ted Chiang

Author

Read the bio

Sougwen Chung

Artist & (re)searcher

Read the bio

Christina J. Colclough

Founder
The Why Not Lab

Read the bio

Barry S. Coller

Vice President for Medical Affairs
The Rockefeller University

Read the bio

Savvas Daniilidis

Student 

Read the bio

Kanta Dihal

Research Fellow
Leverhulme Centre for the Future of Intelligence, University of Cambridge

Read the bio

Αnnie Dorsen

Director 

Read the bio

Andreas Dracopoulos

Co-President, SNF 

Read the bio

Elize Dracopoulos

Student

Read the bio

Nicolas Economou

CEO
H5

Read the bio

Madeleine Elish

Program Director
AI on the Ground Initiative 
Data & Society

Read the bio

Ypatia Fafalios

Student

Read the bio

Panagiotis Fanoulis

Student 

Read the bio

Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein

President and CEO
International Peace Institute

Read the bio

Haris Ioannou

Product Manager in Machine Learning and Cybersecurity
Kleiner Perkins VC and Open Raven

Read the bio

Lucas Joppa

Chief Environmental Officer
Microsoft

Read the bio

Konstantinos Karachalios

Managing Director
IEEE Standards Association

Read the bio

Garry Kasparov

Scholar, Humanitarian, Former World Chess Champion

Read the bio

Anja Kaspersen

Former Director
United Nations for Disarmament Affairs

Read the bio

Kelly Kiki

Project Manager Lab at iMEdD, Journalist

Read the bio

Harold S. Koplewicz

MD Founding President and Medical Director
Child Mind Institute

Read the bio

Sam Koplewicz

Director
Voter Protection for the Florida Democratic Party

Read the bio

Aarathi Krishnan

Research Fellow
Berkman Klein Centre and Carr Centre for Human Rights,  Harvard University

Read the bio

Jason Edward Lewis

Director 
Initiative for Indigenous Futures

Read the bio

K Allado-McDowell

Founder
Artists + Machine Intelligence Program, Google AI

Read the bio

Sabelo Mhlambi

Founder
Bantucracy

Read the bio

Nicolas Miailhe

Co-founder & President
The Future Society (TFS)

Read the bio

Yeshimabeit Milner

Executive Director and Co-Founder
Data for Black Lives

Read the bio

Maria Papadopoulou

Student 

Read the bio

Panos Papoulias

Chief Operating Officer
SNF

Read the bio

Tenzin Priyadarshi

President & CEO
The Dalai Lama Center for Ethics and Transformative Values, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Read the bio

Kevin Rudd

President and CEO
Asia Society

Read the bio

Daniela Rus

Erna Viterbi Professor of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Director of the Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL), MIT
Deputy Dean of Research in the Schwarzman College of Computing, MIT

Read the bio

Anasuya Sengupta

Co-Director and Co-founder
Whose Knowledge?

Read the bio

David Simas

CEO
Obama Foundation

Read the bio

Bing Song

Vice President, Director
Berggruen Institute China Center

Read the bio

Henry Timms

President and CEO 
Lincoln Center

Read the bio

Thanasis Troboukis

Journalist – Project Manager iMEdD Lab

Read the bio

Liam Young

Co-Founder
Tomorrows Thoughts Today

Read the bio

Wendell Wallach

Technology Ethicist
Yale University

Read the bio

Xiaowei Wang

Creative Director
Logic Magazine

Read the bio

George Zarkadakis

Leader for Future of Work
Willis Towers Watson

Read the bio 

Andrew Zolli

Vice-President
Planet, Inc.

Read the bio

Archive